Sunday, August 24, 2008

Packet One WiMAX offering

Over the last few days, since Packet One launched its WiMAX service, a lot of people has been asking me whether it is worth subscribing or is the package too expensive?

Here's what I have to say. Given the scenario below, I hope you can find the answers.

Scenario- P1 offers a cheap WiMAX broadband service and everyone will be subscribing to their cheap 1Mbps service. At this moment, some 5-10% Maxis & Celcom 3G broadband users are sucking up 80-95% of the available bandwidth, and most of this 3G users are using P2P on the lower end plans such as the one priced @ RM68. Do you want to enjoy the same experiences as you were on Celcom 3G or Maxis 3G?

Since broadband services are shared in this country, you will be lucky if you get 1Mbps on Izzi's so called 4G broadband service today. If P1 priced it's broadband services for example 1Mbps @ RM68 a month, a lot of people will subscribe to it and eventually you don't get the speed that you are paying for.

Since P1 is subsidizing the current WiMAX modem, recruiting new staffs, installing new base stations to extend coverage, buying more bandwidth and paying for the current bandwidth, it could kill the WiMAX company before it can even start making the first profit if it offers a cheap 1Mbps service.

The MCMC has committed it self to ensure that all broadband provider to country to offer at least 70% of the offering speed at all time. This means that you will be getting minimum 700Kbps at all time if you are subscribed to a 1Mbps service (it might take years, since it is MCMC). P1 is already on track for this.

P1's CEO Michael Lai has committed that P1 will do everything it can to ensure users are getting the speed that they are paying for. As for those of you who did not know, Michael Lai(pict. above in black shirt) was the ex-CEO of TMNet. He resigned from the company due to some reasons.

In the same time, if P1 is offering a highly priced WiMAX service, than no one will be subscribing to their service, this will also kill them.

So, in simple words, if P1 is offering a cheap WiMAX service, they will go out of business. The same thing will happen if they offer expensive WiMAX packages.

If you you have any bad experience with the P1 WiMAX services or if it is taking so long for you to receive the modem, send me an email and be assured that the CEO of P1 will be informed on this.

At this moment, P1 is looking into offering a P2P only package for P2P users. What do you think about this? Opinions and suggestions are appreciated, please send me an email-malaysianwireless(at)gmail.com

13 comments:

Unknown said...

Malaysian broadband has to come down in price if we were to move forward. Streamyx' 1mbps for RM99 is a joke and it looks like P1's offering of 1.2mbps for RM99 is a half-baked attempt to get broadband subscribers away from Streamyx. There's a few problems for P1 (a consumer's perspective):

1. It's not cheap enough. Why stop at 1.2mbps? Try pricing 2mbps @RM99 and then we'll talk. Why? See below.

2. Wireless sucks. Its performance varies too much. Perhaps the bad service by various wireless broadband services by Maxis and Celcom has left a bad taste. I know WiMAX is a different technology but the general concensus is that Streamyx offers better consistent speed compared to current wireless solutions. So if this stigma is to be broken, a stronger reason is needed motivation to entice the common joe to try WiMAX. Price is the key.

3. Very little coverage. Even in KV, WiMAX by P1 covers on a few areas. This again makes it look like a half-baked attempt. It's freakin' wireless. How hard is it to have more base stations before you roll-out the damn thing? Are they testing the waters? Or banking on the monies of the current subscribers to fund future base stations? Either way, smells half-baked to me (again).

What P1 has going for it is the free modem. Not in the sense that they're throwing in freebies but in that they're making it easier for subscribers to hit the ground running with the service.

I'm still crossing my fingers and hoping that P1 can make a dent in Streamyx' monopoly.

Anonymous said...

Ditto what Bernie said. Couldn't have said it better.

Anonymous said...

I agree with what Bernie say.I am on maxis broadband and connection is not stable.No matter how a wired connection is still much more reliable in my view.But too bad reliability is not found in Streamyx as i experience frequent disconnection too.Now we have wimax,adsl,hsdpa connections but main complain is they are all not reliable.What next?Fibre?How stable can it be is still to be seen.

Unknown said...

JQ,
i agreed with u that wired connection is the most reliable. But what a shame that in our country, this didn't happen.

Anonymous said...

Bernie is absolutely right. Look at our neighbor - Singpore. Their broadband is even more reliable than us and charged with reasonable price.

Anonymous said...

Both Celcom's & Maxis's 3G service is a farce! Subscribers can only look forward to terrible surfing speeds most of the time.

Streamyx is no angle in the broadband issue, but they are currently the lesser evil when compared to the 3G services.

Right now the rule I live by is "Wired broadband over wirelss broadband anytime!"

Will WiMax succeed where 3G has failed - I personally am a wee bit skeptical of it coming true. Though I do have my fingers crossed in the hope for a better broadband future for Malaysians.

Anonymous said...

Have any of you tried the service yet? From what I tested at PC Fair, its fast and reliable. Latency times are better if not on par as wired connections. I hope you have personally tried before throwing conclusion that it is bad.

However I do agree that pricing and charges could have been better for people to subscribe.

Anonymous said...

There's a reason why wireless can't be cheap and has higher cost.

For starters, it's freaking wireless. As in, you can surf anywhere where reception is good.

Compared with Streamyx, which is fixed, you can use WiMax like citywide WiFi.

That's good enough for me.

P1 should have charged more than they do now. Charging like Streamyx for 4G service, I have no idea they're going to survive.

As long as the reception is as good as mobile phone, speed at least 70%, it's actually a bargain.

One thing that I agree is that they shouldn't oversell their bandwidth. At least with Streamyx, you can actually download around 10% within the max bandwidth if you're not using P2P.

Citywide WiMax is more than adequate, but their pricing is comparative with 3G, when WiMax is 4G. I wonder how they will survive.

Anonymous said...

"some 5-10% Maxis & Celcom 3G broadband users are sucking up 80-95% of the available bandwidth"

Can u please elaborate on this? Does a user who subscribe on unlimited broadband not allowed to use maximum download and upload speed for 24 hours non stop?

scamboy said...

Dear Anonymous(Sept,21),

Drop me an email and i would explain to you.

Anonymous said...

This is the problem of all wireless broadband, at one stage congestion will occur. Live with it ... don't expect P1 don't have down time. Wimax is still very new imagine P1 network haven't implement subscriber idle status, so not entire bandwidth is 'share' freely among active/inactive user, FORGET about MIMO-B or Beamforming technology!! expect to see system stability in end of 2009!! when you expect less from P1, you'll feel much more better :)

Anonymous said...

What if it rains?

Anonymous said...

won't be affected.