Monday, June 29, 2009

Celcom Broadband Not Number 1 on Speed

Celcom is currently the Number 1 mobile broadband provider in Malaysia. True, but the question here is are they number 1 in speed as well?

Take a look at the screen shots below(using Celcom HSDPA), taken around 11.30pm on June 28, 2009(Sunday).

Please open image in a separate window for a larger view:

Celcom 3G crawling speed on YouTube
Ping to YouTube (Some hops failed to response, beginning in Local Network)
Ping to Facebook.com (Indicating a serious problem with Celcom3G)
Ping to celcom.com.my (Slow from the very beginning, indicating a serious problem with Celcom3G)
I will not say that this is what you experience all the time, there are time where you get very good speed on Celcom 3G, but not all the time.

It is true that this was tested on Sunday night where it is during peak hours, but this proof something, Celcom3G is oversubscribed because I don't get speed faster than 3G although I am on a HSDPA package. It also shows that the network does not have enough bandwidth to support users at peak time.

It is believed that Celcom signs up approximately 20,000 broadband users in Central region every month(not official) but they don't upgrade their network bandwidth to cope with this extra 20k customers every month.

3G network has their limits, unless you upgrade the network and bandwidth, don't sign up for new customers. It is good for business(signing up new customers) but customer experience is much more important.

I understand this from a technical point of view, but a normal user out there will not understand this as they want a reliable, fast internet connection whenever they want to use it.

Celcom, it is time to upgrade your network or slow down your new sign ups. Being number 1 is good, but think of your current subscribers who made you number 1, do you want to let them down?

P.s: I will continue to make one post on Celcom 3G speedtest every month, if results are disappointing.

Note: This is my opinion and does not represent any organization, companies or any publications out there.

9 comments:

chun said...

How does Maxis 3G network compare?

Unknown said...

true2...
ping to facebook is really bad...

Azbahri said...

haha, as i suspected.. i am celcom broadband user too, and most of my college as well..

celcom cannot handle too many subscribers.. 20k new users per month? wohooo..

celcom broadband perform well early year, but now not anymore.

Beautiful Tonight said...

This is problem faced by many wireless 3G bb providers. Let the King claim the title and he shall fall, one day!

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
FUNG Sai Hou said...

Hi K. Kugan,

Thank you for such info and share with us. I agreed what you mentioned in the blog. As Celcom is really Widest Coverage in Nationwide, but service / speed is not the fastest and the speed is not stable as the Telco D.

I used to be Celcom users but now switch to Telco D as Celcom cannot provide good service in my residential area.

Rosie said...

I totally agree with this blog. As I am a currently a Celcom user as well. Guess other operator will be facing this issue as well.

Edmund Seet said...

I am with Celcom broadband as well but with the 384Kbps package. Celcom should upgrade the speed for the price we are paying ... otherwise, one should consider switching to Maxis or Digi. The downside of switching now it is that Maxis' and Digi's 3G network coverage is not as wide as Celcom's but they are expanding. Celcom, please buck up or else you will lose out.

Kumar said...

Kugan, truly agree with you man. I think they are over
Selling and speed really has fallen
Off a cliff !! Axiata is more interested
To buy out other mobile operators in
India, Sri Lanka an so on, instead of spending
Money in malaysia which is a cash cow to
Them. I have switched
To Maxis wireless, cheaper and more stable.
I get better value and customer support
Is really top class. I am not paid to
Do this..... Really think that the
Maxis boys are getting it right.