U Mobile is reshaping again, probably the fourth time.
In April 2009, I made a blog post titled "Complications in U Mobile?" which reveals part of the issues that U Mobile is facing, even now, however the post was removed at the request of U Mobile with promise that they will respond to me. If you had been following my blog, you know that they never responded.
This time their two foreign investors are saying "Goodbye" to U Mobile. KTF in April 2009 said that it will be selling all its 16.5% stake in U Mobile, while last week DoCoMo also decided to do the same thing. It is reported that the departure of KTF and DoCoMo is because of their "disagreement with other shareholders over management", however there could be more reasons, but I guess I won't be able to share it here.
There has been talks/rumours that the new management team that has been put together by Tan Sri Vincent Tan involves an appointment of a CEO who was previously with Axiata. However this remains a possibility until U Mobile announce the new management team.
What U Mobile needs to do?
Here's a simple conclusion on the company:
Pricing: Not the lowest
Free Phones: Competitors has better offer
3G Coverage: Expanding but like a turtle
Advantage: None
Mistakes: Killing DVB-H, losing a number of good staffs, Kenneth Chang (Executive Director of U Mobile) is no longer running the day-to-day business at the company, foreign investors leaving, failed business plans.
First up, it needs to be different from the other telcos. When it first started, the company was shouting about its 1-second billing, apparently it is not working since the company only has close to a couple hundreds of thousand customers(not even 1% of the mobile market), plus their mobile plans has been the same for a very long time if compared to competitors.
On top of all these, I can confidently say that they have no advantage at all over their competitors. The question here is, what are the goals of U Mobile? Does it plan to capture the voice & sms market in Malaysia with their 3G spectrum?
As a 3G operator, what type of 3G services do they have? The last time I met one of the person in the content development team, they were still trying to learn about mobile contents! U Mobile has to re-look at their business plans- Who's their target of subscribers? What do these subscribers want?
In comparison to Tune Talk, the new MVNO company had 10,000 subscribers way before launching their service! If U Mobile wants to remain in the industry, it has to be aggressive, find the right people to run the company, and look above voice, SMS and even 3G! But right now, it is no where close to that.
Why should you use U Mobile when DiGi, Maxis and Celcom are better in all aspects (management, offering, investment)?
Related:
Monday, September 21, 2009
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

8 comments:
I personally like their per second billing, but agree that their overall charge should be cheaper.
Their 3G Internet service is second only to DiGi, having used all four providers, both in terms of pricing, reliability, and speed. But their coverage needs to expand fast!
IMHO, they still need to build their own 2G network - which is the only way they can truly compete. Riding on Siaocom's network (for 2G) give this impression that they are a second class company. IMO again, Malaysia is unsuitable still for a pure 3G network.
@Diesel Electric,
Why should U Mobile build a 2G network when the world is moving toward LTE and 4G?
More Malaysians are IT savvy now, high numbers on social network, more than 100% mobile penetration, if 3G is not working then the operators are to blame, not consumers.
I would prefer Maxis and Celcom for mobile broadband because the service is made for people on the move.
I dunno, Kugan, but the general impression I get is 3G is not moving ahead as a replacement standard for normal voice calls, at least in this country. 3G has been in Malaysia for about five years now, and all we have been getting are complaints and substandard services. And these are all Internet-related gripes. The only reason mobile 3G uptake is 'soaring' is because there really isn't much change to fixed line alternatives for Internet access. If U Mobile thinks it can get a slice of the market for mobile telephony on purely 3G, all I can say is for now I do not foresee that happening. A few friends working for different telcos have all said investment for 3G infra is coming to a standstill due to soaring cost.
I think 3G is only suitable for a country with dense and more or less uniformly distributed population e.g. Japan. For a country like Malaysia, 2G is still the way to go. I have not noticed much decrease in the prices of 3G handsets the last few years, and most people I know don't use 3G for video calls anyway - one of the main selling points of 3G for Malaysian cel cos. I do agree that cel cos are also responsible for the 'failure' of 3G. Coverage is one thing, the ridiculously low data transfer limit is also dragging 3G down (Singapore 3G broadband offers, on average, 30GB a month). If there is a future for 3G, IMO it lies with data service provision i.e. Internet access.
Which brings me to my next point: Even for Internet access, I think 3G is not too terribly suitable. The inherents of the technology basically makes it impossible to support more users while maintaining a satisfactory experience. Throw in what my friends tell me as mentioned in the previous para, I'm more convinced Malaysian 3G will be stuck in an indefinite rut. IMHO, WiMAX is the way forward for mobile broadband. The cost to upgrade a mobile basestation's ability to support more users is far cheaper for WiMAX than 3G. No expert, of course.
Just my two cents.
Diesel Electric,
I am totally agree with you. 3G is good when come to download or browsing low dense content like short video, mms etc. 1-2-1 video call is dying. No one in this part of the world loves to see boring face. Video call is merely 1-2-1 video conferencing with lag voice and video. It can't replace the instantly and spontaneous conventional voice call and can'
t be delay SMS. Imagine video call in a public area, the background noise makes it a stupid idea.
3G Internet broadband is just a stepping stone or sub product for the exiting celco who want to jump into Internet bandwagon. Wireless broadband is still better on 4G Wimax and Izzinet technology. The lack of service level of 3G will bring home user of Internet BB to frustration. There are tons of complaints to Maxis and Celcom on their BB service. 3G W-CDMA operators better stick to mobile users who just access tolerance speed data connection on their blackberry and small form devices.
U Mobile want voice and sms to be their money making in the current 3G? The soaking of 3G cost make it a fragile business case. Further with their only 3G license, they need to rely on 2G provider (Celcom) to provide voice and sms only service area. The without data on Celcom roaming is a terrible idea. Imagine if their users step into Celcom territory which is 90% of U mobile service area (thru roaming) and can't access data and mms, what is the use of subscribing to U Mobile plan? Must well stick to DiGi, Celcm and Maxis who offer full data network!!
U Mobile is a mistake. Unless they fast enought to cover the strategic areas of the nation with full 3G, else we will say bye bye to U Mobile.
The only area of voice business they can step into is the lubricate IDD calls to Indonesia, Vietnam, Bangladesh, India where all our foreign work powers are. This group of users don't complain much like the highly IT savvy Malaysian!
In SE Asia, Thailand, Vietnam, Loas, Cambodia are no rushing to built 3G networks but to maintain good 2G network and make the cost of voice and sms to lowest. Malaysia still has the higher voice call and sms charges in the region. Believe me!
Australia and HK has cases of 3G license only operator failure. Those operators are either merge or acquired by another 2G+3G operator in the country.
But don't ask U Mobile to built 2G network from sratch, else they will be like turtle..
Yeah, their marketing and product planning are sucked. No new products out.
and it's better for the NTT Docomo and KTF to go as I never see any announcement by the new foreign managing directors speaking after the entry of the 2 JK investors... What is the inside story that has happened, Kugan?
U Mobile delay billing is another minus point.
@beautiful tonight,
totally agree with you. another example of 3G only license telco failure is in the Philippines. a company named U Mobile and later renamed to Red Mobile and now acquired by another larger operator "Smart Cellular".
perhaps all company named "U Mobile" have to face failure?.
that's my personal opinion.
Actually, 3G still has a bright future. It is a lot easier to upgrade 3G infrastructure to LTE than to start LTE from scratch. We all know LTE is a lot better than other so called "4G" technologies.
Instead of losing out in the 2G market now, U mobile should probably just focus entirely on wireless broadband as their niche. When the transition from 3G to LTE arrives in Malaysia, those with 3G licenses might finally hit gold.
2G should be transitioned out as soon as possible due to security issues. The fact that all the major mobile telcos in this country are using the GSM system as opposed to CDMA means all share the same vulnerabilities with the weak A5 cypher. So its very fortunate that UMTS (3G) was introduced in Malaysia years back as opposed to now, regardless if it was expensive or not.
i like your blog, always speak what is inside our mind too.
Post a Comment