Monday, September 28, 2009

P1 is an example to the Broadband Industry

It is the 1st time(that I know) an ISP in Malaysia has come out publicly and ask users to provide feedback on their service, whether it is good or bad.

“We regard those who send us negative comments as our best friends; only a good friend will be honest and frank,” said its chief marketing officer, Kenny Wong-source

P1 is currently the only ISP in the country to open various active channel for customers to provide feedback on their service. These channels include their customer hotline, email, social networks, dealers and more.

Personally, I have seen the man himself(CEO of P1, Michael Lai) apologising to customers and following up a customer's complaint despite his busy schedule. From Marketing, Corp Comm, to Product, I have not seen a team of people who are passionate with their work, open to feedback, and serious with what they do.

How many CEOs have you seen "turun padang"(coming down) to their own roadshows or booths to help out? None? Well, Michale Lai is one of them.

If you walk up to an ISP to complaint about their lousy service, in most cases they will put a blame on something that does not relate back to them. In this case P1 is different, they accept the critics and in the same tries to resolve the problem. Although you may not experience this at all levels(example: customer service), the management has been trying their level best to improve customer experience, for an example, the people who handles P1's Twitter account is not part of the customer service team.

I am not saying P1 is perfect, but their willingness to improve the service sets a good example to the broadband industry in Malaysia. It is not that the other ISPs are not improving, but how to improve if they are not doing the best to listen to their own customers, get feedback? Even the biggest ISP in the country, TMNet doesn't have any social networking presence when it is estimated millions of Malaysian are using social media.

ISPs need to change! If you offer an Internet service, you don't communicate with your broadband customers through the phone. Malaysians deserve a better broadband experience.

11 comments:

Unknown said...

While I agree that more Msian companies should provide more channels of communication, I don't agree that P1 is an example. The reason TMNet is not doing it now, is bcoz they need to have a structure and processes in place to handle such enquiries. No point offering such channels if you can't respond effectively. And I agree with them bcoz it will only add to the customer's frustration.

On P1, Kenny Wong, thats their marketing guy talking. He's selling.

P1 is using these channels for marketing not receiving feedback. I havent seen them using these channels to reach out to customers (by making service announcements) other than selling.

They are not responding to feedback or complaints. Just go to their Facebook page and you can see the huge number of negative feedback and frustrated customers. They are not responding to complaints thru their website (that is another channel).

What is the point of being on twitter but when someone complaints, a standard response is given "Email your problem to talktous@p1.com.my" but then there is no response.

And I have to strongly disagree with ur sentence in red. I'm a consultant for rightnow.com and I know the fact is an angry customer's 1st reaction is to pick up the phone to call you, not login into FB or twitter. (How can they do so if they can't get a connection?)

I'm not even sure if they have SLAs in place with regards to resolving customer complaints bcoz of the 10+ calls I've made, I've been told different resolution times.

Perhaps Michael Lai could take a page out of what some companies are doing to improve customer interaction.

Tony Fernandes gave his email out there for the public & actually replied! Now that tells me he was serious about receiving feedback & complaints.

Malaysia Airlines held meet the customer sessions. Digi provided online Chat.

So until P1 can really have a dedicated channel for gathering feedback & show some action, it's just a marketing guy trying to get more subscribers.

I could go on forever but I'm not sure whether my P1 line is still connected. :P

You have a good day now. :)

warbaby said...

Hey Adrian. Thanks for the honest and direct feedback. We are still in the process of setting up our response structure, and we are listening.

We apologise for the difficulty you have been facing, and would like to fix it for you. Immediate action can sometimes be our weakness as we depend on a number of links in the process chain, but I assure you it's not because we don't care. I'm copying this post to the senior management of P1, and I will not ask you to email to support. Email to me directly - my email is james.chong@greenpacket.com. I was the head of products in p1,and now am working together with the P1 senior management in establishing a quicker, better and more efficient response structure. Like they say, you can never improve enough :)

P1 has been operating for about 13 months, and we still have a lot of catching up to do with companies like AA, MAS and DiGi, who have now gone way past the startup and expansion phase (DiGi has at least 15 years head start over P1!), and can concentrate wholeheartedly in tweaking their already well oiled machine even better. We have to do both at the same time - set up the network and service, and work on being even better than the rest in customer service :)

In the meantime, please write to me and I will make sure the relevant people gets things fixed for you.

My full details are below:

James Chong
Chief Executive
ruumzNation Sdn Bhd
twitter: warbaby
mobile number: +60162131133
email: james.chong@greenpacket.com
ruumz: james.ruumz.com
twitter: warbaby
facebook: warbaby
MSN: spacecadetblues@hotmail.com

Daniel Y.S. Tan said...

Hi All,

Am writing here as a 'veteran' P1 user who got-in the Wimax bandwagon user-experience about 12 months ago. I had a good start for at least 4 months before P1 got too popular and congested. I was already almost regretting my subscription decision. However, fast-forwarding to just only a recent 2-weeks or so ago, i had an interesting experience i wish to share now after reading the article and comments here.

I had so much bandwidth problems with P1 then up to recently, and since i had a couple of bad experiences with customer service and heard more around me about P1 outsourcing their customer service out to X company which would mean they would 'care less' since it's no longer talking to their Managers if the customer support is unable to handle my complaints. I was freaking-out to the tune of paying RM99 for less than 30-40% bandwidth for the next 12-months i was contracted to and didn't know how to get-out of it if it persisted.

I even contemplated with the idea that moving back to a 'dinosaur' broadband co. would be a better idea after all and resign to the fact all broadband is the same out there in Malaysia.

However, about 2 months ago, with relentless tweeting from time to time and eventually got hold to a nice guy like Kenny Wong who works in P1 and riding on 'Tweet-PoweR' (using Twitter to channel my grouses and grieve) got me where i think conventional customer service would have taken ages to sort-out!

Guess what? They did reply and listened to my rantings though i was a bit skeptical at first. They could have just simply ignored & renegade on a tweeter reply to sort-out my problems having had this issue over emails with another broadband co. Also, since it was 'just' a conversational tweet but i have to say social media is very much alive here.

Anyhow, to cut the story short, they fixed a permanent modem at my place at no cost and if i'm not mistaken, there's a 1-month bill waiver on their side i'm looking to get answer from P1. I thank them for getting me-out of many months of bad connectivity with such efficient replies via Twitter if the processing links will take a bit of time to fulfill my 1-month bill waiver.

Still, it's been a good customer service experience via social media! P1 is definitely the first to use it effectively on bringing cheer to their customers. It's time to tweet them Adrian and all you P1 users out there! Follow them in Twitter @P1Media & just put your 140-character comments and hashtag and the end of each sentence #P1Wimax or #P1 and you'll see wonders from them. I see a bright Wimax future for Malaysia.

Yours truly,
Daniel Y.S. Tan
Twitter me: DanevO
Your regular P1 user

Anonymous said...

largest broadband service provider...
failed to provide the bast services...

http://www.vincentchow.net/2707/speed-test-streamyx-vs-p1-wimax

CZQ said...

can WiMAX provide voice/SMS services like GSM/CDMA mobile phone ?

Unknown said...

Hi Daniel,

Glad that you got ur problem rectified. I am still (as you put it) in the 'relentless tweeting from time to time' phase. :P

No status update, no permanent modem at no cost and no 1-month bill waiver yet. Well anyway since James responded above, I will give my two cents worth after this.

I have no doubt social media can be used effectively to enhance the customer experience. I can tell you that I have been meeting w a lot of Msian companies and even GLCs who are jumping on the bandwagon.

Getting support from these channels shouldn't be that difficult. Why did you have to 'relentlessly' tweet b4 you got someone to respond to you. Its not hard for P1 to setup a @P1Care on twitter. This would just be another channel. We shouldn't need to run around in circles before we get connected to the right people. Have a look at this, http://www.outsideline.co.uk/blog/2009/07/13/bt-rethink-customer-service-with-the-help-of-twitter/. This is how our clients are harnessing the power of social media. No hashtag. Companies like BT, Telstra, etc understand that each complaint, even via non-direct channels must be responded to in today's fast paced internet age. It's about maintaining customer and brand loyalty. Have you been on P1's facebook page?

In my case here, I am surprised that it had to come to me posting a comment here, for scamboy to tweet about it to p1w1max, james and kenny before james responded. Not that I don't appreciate his generous offer to get things fixed for me.

Did you say permanent modem at no cost? :)

You have a good day.

Krista Goon said...

I tweeted about my friend's problem with P1 here in Penang before someone from P1 on Twitter responded. I hope their rate of response is as good as their rate of tweeting! I am not a user of P1 but at the rate my friend was going on and on, he was clearly upset and dissatisfied. However, it is a good strategy for P1 to use today's social media tools to raise their profile and create a perception that they are fast, up-to-date and listening to their customers. I was pretty impressed when they picked up on my bitching about it on twitter with a friend. Both of us blogged about it too. Will my friend get better P1 service? I hope to hear positive news from him the next time I see him! In case you are interested, my blog post is here: http://www.redboxstudio.com/blog/2009/10/how-twitter-helped-this-p1-wimax-business/

Unknown said...

Hi James,

Thanks for the reply. I believe my problems (technical) are the same for any other P1 customer just like Daniel's. Extremely slow speeds, frequent disconnections, etc. I have to say first and foremost that I understand there will always be teething issues with any new technology setups. This is the norm. I signed up expecting that there will be days when its not up to par.

My biggest complaint and frustration is not on the technology side but on your customer service. It's already frustrating to be disconnected for long periods but to not get a satisfactory level of service from your call centre agents and your other channels only worsens it ten fold (or perhaps more) :P

Getting someone to solve my problems is secondary. My main goal is providing you with feedback. Only with feedback can you improve. I did ask your serv.rep for a name/email that I could write to give my feedback. Unfortunately he didn't know anyone he could refer me to.

Seriously dealing with your reps really raises one's blood pressure. Ditto AndyChin. http://twitter.com/andychin/status/4670440472

The words "I don't know" should never be uttered to a customer by a service rep..... ten fold.

I don't mind a serv.rep telling me that there is some technical problems with my base station or u guys are conducting maintenance work but give me a timeline when things will be back to normal. Asking me to call again tomorrow if I still don't get a connection by then..... ten fold.

Closing my case as resolved within the next day because I didn't call is not the way to keep unresolved cases down.

Not responding to my emails via whatever channels I used, doesn't show that P1 is listening.

I'm reading comments on your fb page that someone's complaint hasn't been resolved for 2 weeks. Surely your SLAs are shorter than that. My current problem on speed and frequent disconnection started on Sunday morning, still no signs of improvement till today. Case noted via twitter on Monday, called call centre on Tuesday, raised to level 2 and I don't know what's next. I don't know if someone is acting on it. No one has called me back since. Again I'm left in the dark.

Anyway, if P1 can start actively responding and engaging customers instead of leaving them hanging in the dark, could cut down on the number of unhappy customers. You need customers to start talking positively about P1.

The hundreds of negative comments on P1's FB page is somewhat being ignored. One post about your potong campaign is followed by tons of angry comments. More on your wall. You can't ignore those. It's not good for your brand. It puts off the neutrals who joined your page.

You should start empowering your customers, give them a dedicated channel to voice their grouses. Start a @P1Care twitter or a P1Care FB page. Engage them there instead of using your marketing channels.

If you are working towards better customer service, have a look at http://www.rightnow.com/strategy-eight-steps.php?cin=2130. There are also tons of free downloadable whitepapers and business cases of how companies like BT, Telstra, Nikon, BA, etc. improved their service delivery, maintaining an effective connection between the company and customers.

Thanks for taking time to read my little rant here. Hope to see some initiatives from P1.

Cheers.

ps: I want what Daniel has. :P

Cynthia Seow said...

Hi Adrian,
Appreciate your comments. Allow me to assist you further please. In order to do so, i need you to get in touch with me. Can you please email your details to me at cynthia.seow@packet-1.com.

I would be happy to assist further.

Thanks

Cheers,
Cynthia Seow

HealthScreening said...

Dear P1 friends,

I'm facing frequent disconnection & slow internet speed... Even at 1am midnight.. I understand upgrade do need time, but it took more than 4 months to upgrade the service in my area. Initially P1 distributor promised that service is good, customer service is good, bla bla bla.. but end of the day, i'm suffered.

I do need a stable and fast internet speed for my communication with my colleague in overseas. Sometimes meeting have to canceled or delay due to my absence (cannot connect to internet...

Customer service personnel promised me that they will get technician to contact me or come to my house and solve the problem for me... but end up with disappointment.

Appreciate if your team can do something to improve the service, at least to show other country that P1 is a company who really serious in Wimax business...

Unknown said...

me using p1 wimax for about 12months now.. yes i know how frustrated it gets when the connection is not stable.. i oso have the experience, particularly during early november.. i got so fedup until call their careline and attack them in whatever channel on internet that i can.. suddenly they come, do some tweeking, and the connection is improving since then.. i know, broadband based on sharing connection.. if the area is congested such as Shah Alam sec.7, then the signal can be a lil bit ....... but i when i spend my time last week at shah alam, the speed is ok.. i blog about it too.. you can see the speed during not so congested population.. it's quite good actually...