Saturday, September 26, 2009

Service Disruption on Celcom Network

If you were in one of the "Ini adalah Wilayah Celcom", you might had trouble in making and receiving calls using Celcom.

Muktamad! Celcom's network went down last Thursday(24 September, 09) started about 9.30am leaving more than a million Celcom users in the dark for more than 10 hours. Please read official news here.

Although Celcom claims the problem has been resolved, yet a number of users has been complaining on the 25 September 09 that they were some difficulties in making and receiving call, plus delayed SMS & slow mobile broadband.

When Celcom merged with TM Touch, the cellular unit of Telekom Malaysia in the year 2003, it lost a number of mobile users through the years. Back then Celcom was the leading telco in the country, because it had the right branding and network quality was great.

The new Celcom that we see today is different. They are at least 5 operators sharing the traffic on Celcom's GSM network(U Mobile, XOX, Tune Talk, Merchantrade, REDtone) making it the largest GSM network in the country with one of the highest traffic. The question here is, can Celcom handle these traffic? Apparently, we have seen the results for the past two days. Are they planning for more MVNOs?

Their 3G network currently has the highest traffic in the country with over 420,000 mobile broadband users and these numbers does not include normal data usage on the phone and other sources (such as the TNB Meter readers, ATMs..etc).

When a user has problems with their mobile service, the 1st thing they would do is to contact the customer service. When Celcom's network went down last Thursday, the second thing went down was their Helpline(1111), and at the same time they were no immediate updates on Celcom's website or their accounts on social networking until a couple hours later but it was too late.

It is important to use all sort of communications to let their own customers know about the network breakdown before even the customers find out, but Celcom choose to leave them in the dark. Even yesterday, no sms or apologies where sent out to customers. Is this the NUMBER 1 experience that Celcom is trying to give?

What Celcom should have done:
  • Update their social networking status- They should have communicated with a number of their mobile users using their existing accounts in social network such as Facebook.
  • Update their website- Their web team was extremely slow in putting up a notice on their website when the network went down. Supposedly, the notice should be up within an hour but I guess not many users even bothered to visit the Celcom website thanks to its superb design and outdated contents.
  • Domestic Roaming- When Celcom network was having problem, Maxis and DiGi network did not had any issues. If only there was a domestic agreement signed between these telcos, this post won't even exist because they wouldn't be any users complaining.
  • Send an apology message- Did Celcom notice that a large number of people was cursing them on Twitter? If I were Celcom, I would have sent a direct apology message to all these Celcom customers including those cursing for not being able to call a Celcom number.
  • Rebates/Discount on billing/airtime- Should Celcom customers get free calls/usage for one day? Let's see how Celcom value their customers.
Before I forgot, in 2007 here's what Celcom claimed- Number 1

The last time I reported Celcom had network problem was in November last year.

11 comments:

mafiz said...

Classic example of avalanche effect due to frequency/spectrum limitation. Imagine critical sectors like security or healthcare services on GSM platform. Somebody could be dying and there's no communication. Even if celcos are sharing infra, I don't think it would be able to support all 26 million subs.

3G/4G/LTE, the fact is they're all limited by spectrum. I wonder how can they deliver triple play services with guaranteed QOS. Fiber optics on the other hand gives you abundance of capacities with multiple redundancies. There should be interworking between all carriers especially with Fixed operators to optimise capacity deployment geographically and not just 'cherry picking'.

Interworking is critical. In an all IP environment, services/subs would be able to roam across networks seamlessly. At that time, we would no longer be known by the phone number, just identity. Traffic (with QOS) can be load shared by NSPs. Question is when are they gonna do this?

I'm one of Celcom's unfortunate customers. If only we have WIFI access all over. That could be a good alternative with truly unlimited broadband!

diod said...

DiGI will very happy sign domestic roaming with Celcom. In fact, Digi try this long time ago but the big telco reject the idea.

Anyway, Digi roaming to celcom network in East-West highway between Baling and Jeli.

Beautiful Tonight said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Azbahri said...

what a terrible incident.. all of my fren keep complaining about celcom since last day huhu..

CZQ said...

Celcom network went down got affected MVNO(Umobile, XOX, TuneTalk, Merchandtrade, Redtone) ???

Mookies said...

today (26/9/09) at 9.30 pm, my celcom line xda bar lansung.....susah bro nk hidup macam ni...nk call pun susah.....xgune cakap kat celcom nie....dorg xkisah sgt dengan customer pulak tue...

chris federick said...

hi dropping by :) nice blog u have here.

Beautiful Tonight said...

my umobile and tunetalk have no problem on Celcom GSM networks.. so its Celcom own node problem..

bravo to all those Celcom worshipper! This is one good reason why not use Celcom..

Nationwide downtime twice in a year time! Celcom relase news that they have no plan for compensation! so EGO!

Marvin Lee said...

Celcom down again I think. No calls in, no calls out! Damn!

Unknown said...

i decide to mnp to maxis.
no more celcom for me!

d@vid said...

Talks about this Celcom website, even some big day they also won't update properly or to greet Malaysian, they are totally useless now.